Luminance Consulting

Book a meeting
English,

Standards and compliance

UGR: understanding the glare rating and its thresholds

What UGR measures, why it depends on the room and the observer, and how to obtain a calculated value that is genuinely usable in a project.

Luminance ConsultingProfessional lighting design office

5 min read

Office corridor lit by recessed LED luminaires

A product data sheet states a UGR below 19. The luminaire is ordered, installed, and the occupants complain of glare from the first week. The contradiction is not really one: the value printed on the sheet describes a theoretical room, rarely the one where the luminaire has just been installed.

What the unified glare rating quantifies

UGR, for unified glare rating, quantifies the discomfort glare felt by an observer facing the luminaires in their field of view. It reflects discomfort, not a loss of visual performance. An occupant can see properly and still suffer from discomfort glare that tires them over the day.

The calculation combines several quantities: the luminance of the luminous parts seen by the observer, their apparent size, their position relative to the line of sight and the background luminance of the room. The scale progresses in perceptible steps, each additional step corresponding to noticeably greater discomfort.

Two related notions are often confused with UGR. Disability glare impairs the perception of detail, for example when facing a poorly aimed floodlight. Reflected glare comes from a glossy surface that sends the image of the source back to the observer. The UGR index deals with neither, and these two phenomena call for different responses.

Why UGR depends on the room and the observer

None of the calculation parameters belongs to the luminaire alone. Background luminance depends on the colours and condition of the walls. Apparent position depends on the ceiling height, the layout grid and where the observer stands. The direction of view changes everything: the same luminaire seen from the side or along its longitudinal axis does not produce the same discomfort.

The consequence is direct. A UGR value given without a description of the room and without an observer position remains incomplete. Two floors fitted with the same product can show different results, one compliant and the other not.

What a UGR stated on a product data sheet means

The value published by a manufacturer generally comes from a tabular method: the luminaire is calculated in a standardised reference room, with conventional dimensions, reflectance values and observer positions. The table gives values for two viewing directions, crosswise and endwise.

This value is used to compare products with one another, which remains useful at the shortlisting stage. It is not a commitment on the result in a real room. A wording such as UGR below 19, with no mention of the reference room, should be completed by the manufacturer. The subject ties in with all the points covered in reading an LED luminaire data sheet.

The thresholds expected by type of activity

The EN 12464-1 standard assigns a maximum UGR to each visual task. The values most frequently encountered in projects are as follows.

Type of activity

Maximum UGR

Technical drawing, high-precision visual tasks

16

Offices, meeting rooms, classrooms

19

Reception, front desk, medium-precision industrial work

22

Rough industrial work, archives

25

Circulation areas and corridors

28

The threshold is always read together with the other criteria for the room: maintained illuminance, uniformity and colour rendering. A room can meet the UGR requirement and still be uncomfortable if its uniformity is insufficient. The lighting compliance page details this combined reading.

Source luminance, optics and diffusers

Controlling glare comes down to the luminance seen by the observer at critical angles. A very bright point source, directly visible, causes far greater discomfort than the same amount of light spread over a larger emitting surface.

There are three families of technical responses:

  • Diffusers, which spread the flux over a larger surface and lower the apparent luminance.
  • Cut-off optics, which limit emission beyond a given angle from the vertical.
  • Luminaires with an indirect component, which use the ceiling as an emitting surface and raise the background luminance of the room.

Each response has a photometric cost. A pronounced cut-off reduces useful lateral flux, which may require additional luminaires to maintain uniformity. The trade-off is made by calculation, not from the catalogue.

Obtaining a calculated UGR in a study

The only genuinely usable value is the one calculated in the project room, with its dimensions, reflectances and observer positions. Lighting calculation software produces this value from the room model and the photometric files of the selected luminaires.

Three elements should be required in the report:

  1. The observer positions adopted, shown on the plan, and the associated viewing directions.
  2. The reflectance values used for the ceiling, walls and floor, consistent with the actual condition of the room.
  3. The UGR value obtained for each zone, presented alongside illuminance and uniformity.

A photometric study carried out on this basis makes it possible to check glare before ordering, including for solutions based on LED panels or other luminaires for offices and workstations.

Dealing with glare in an existing installation

In a room in use, several levers can be tested before considering a complete removal. Reorienting workstations to take luminaires out of the line of sight resolves some of the complaints. Lightening a dark ceiling raises the background luminance and mechanically improves the index. Replacing a degraded diffuser or an unsuitable optic tackles the cause across an entire family of luminaires.

Diagnosis begins with observation from the workstations concerned, at the times when discomfort is reported, recording positions and orientations. This finding, cross-checked with a calculation, shows which lever will produce the expected effect and which will have none.

The cost of these levers bears no comparison with a complete rework of the installation, provided they are tested on a single bay before being rolled out across a whole floor.

To have the UGR of your premises calculated in their real configuration, book a meeting: we will scope your project and send you a quote.

Further reading: EN 12464-1 standard: illuminance levels room by room and Luminance, illuminance, intensity: no more confusing the quantities. Reference: CIE UGR method (CIE 117).

On the equipment side, at Rexylum: DALLE VERTIGO VBL and the Acoustic luminaires range.

Frequently asked questions

What is the UGR index in lighting?
UGR, for unified glare rating, quantifies the discomfort glare experienced by an observer facing the luminaires in their field of view. It expresses discomfort, not a loss of visual performance. Its calculation combines the luminance of the luminous parts seen, their apparent size, their position relative to the line of sight and the background luminance of the room.
What is the maximum UGR by type of activity?
EN 12464-1 assigns a maximum UGR to each visual task: 16 for technical drawing and high-precision tasks, 19 for offices, meeting rooms and classrooms, 22 for reception and medium-precision industrial work, 25 for rough industrial work and archives, 28 for circulation areas.
Does a UGR below 19 on a product data sheet guarantee no glare?
No. The published value generally comes from a tabular method, calculated in a standardised reference room with conventional observer positions. It is useful for comparing products, but it is no commitment on the result in a real room. The only usable value is the one calculated in the project room, with its dimensions, reflectances and observer positions.

Related articles

More articles, those in the same category first.

View all articles
  • Workshop aisle lined with workstations, lit by lines of LED luminairesStandards and compliance

    Lighting at work: what the French Labour Code requires

    Enforceable minimum values, the employer's obligations, how they fit with the EN 12464-1 standard: the legal framework for workplace lighting.

    Luminance ConsultingProfessional lighting design office

    5 min read

  • Break area and office corridor lit by LED luminairesStandards and compliance

    EN 12464-1 standard: illuminance levels room by room

    How to read the EN 12464-1 standard by visual task and find the illuminance in lux, the uniformity and the UGR expected in each workplace.

    Luminance ConsultingProfessional lighting design office

    4 min read

  • Office corridor lit by recessed LED luminairesStandards and compliance

    OPERAT declaration: which lighting data to submit

    How to reconstruct and declare lighting consumption on OPERAT when the building has no dedicated sub-metering.

    Luminance ConsultingProfessional lighting design office

    5 min read