Luminance Consulting

Book a meeting
English,

Audit, renovation and profitability

Relamping or full renovation: how to decide

Layout, condition of the luminaires, warranties, compliance: the criteria for choosing between relamping and a full lighting renovation.

Luminance ConsultingProfessional lighting design office

5 min read

Manufacturing hall lit by suspended LED high bays

At the start of the financial year, the question almost always comes up in the same terms: can we simply change the light sources rather than remove the luminaires? The relamping quote is noticeably lighter and needs no study. In many cases, it also shuts the door on real savings for the next ten years.

What relamping and full renovation actually cover

Relamping means replacing the light sources in the existing luminaires, keeping the housings, optics, supports and often the control gear. A full renovation removes everything and installs new luminaires, with a redefined layout and, where appropriate, a rework of the controls.

Between the two there are intermediate situations: partial removal, keeping the supports, replacing only the optical unit on certain families of luminaires. The choice is made zone by zone, never building by building.

The vocabulary should be fixed from the first meeting. Some suppliers call relamping an operation that includes removing the housings, others reserve the term for changing the source only. A tender launched on a poorly defined word produces offers that do not cover the same scope of works.

When the existing layout rules out simple relamping

The decisive point is the original layout. It was calculated for discharge or fluorescent sources, with different flux distributions and efficiencies. Changing the source in an unsuitable grid reproduces the defects of the installation and locks them in for a long time.

Three signs call for a complete rework:

  • A grid inherited from a layout that no longer exists, with workstations moved since, partitions added or racks raised.
  • Uniformity that was already insufficient before the works, visible as dips in illuminance between luminaires.
  • An unsuitable mounting height or optic, producing hot spots under the luminaires and dark areas between them.

In all three cases, the new source improves consumption without correcting the geometry. The room remains uncomfortable and compliance remains out of reach.

Condition of luminaire housings, optics and supports

Relamping assumes the installed base is in good condition. Yellowed diffusers, oxidised reflectors, hardened gaskets and corroded fixings absorb part of the flux and raise a safety issue. In an ageing luminaire, a new source shines through a diffuser that has lost some of its transmission.

Sealing deserves particular attention in workshops and outdoors. An ingress protection rating stated originally is worthless if the gasket has aged or if the enclosure has been reopened several times. This point is checked luminaire by luminaire during the on-site lighting audit.

Electrical compatibility and warranties after modification

Replacing a source in an existing luminaire modifies that luminaire. Depending on the solution chosen, the ballast must be bypassed or removed, the internal wiring adapted and compatibility with the existing control system checked. Dimming designed for an earlier technology will not necessarily control an LED source.

Two consequences are regularly underestimated. The warranty of the original luminaire lapses as soon as its internal wiring is modified. And whoever modifies the luminaire takes on responsibility for the product thus transformed, with the marking and documentation obligations that go with it. These points are settled before the order, with the contractor who will carry out the works.

Effect on uniformity and on the compliance of the room

The compliance of a room is assessed on several criteria at once: maintained illuminance on the task area, uniformity, glare, colour rendering. Relamping acts mainly on the flux, marginally on the distribution, and not at all on the position of the light points.

Relamping can even degrade an acceptable situation. A more directional source placed in an optic designed for a diffuse source concentrates the flux in the centre and darkens the periphery. The average goes up, uniformity goes down, and complaints appear at the workstation.

The check is made on the task area, not on the room average. Relamping that raises the overall average while leaving an assembly station in a dip in illuminance solves nothing from a compliance point of view, and the acceptance measurement will show it.

Comparing the two scenarios over the operating life

An honest comparison is made over the operating life, not on the purchase price. Five criteria genuinely differentiate the two scenarios.

Criterion

Relamping

Full renovation

Initial investment

Lower, limited supply and installation

Higher, removal and reinstallation included

Room for photometric improvement

Limited to the existing grid

Layout redefined according to the task

Control of compliance

Partial, the geometry stays fixed

Complete, criteria verified by simulation

Warranty and liability

To be re-established after modification

Carried by the new luminaire

Controls and detection

Depending on the compatibility of the existing system

Built in from the design stage

The detailed calculation method is set out in our article on the real cost of LED lighting over ten years. The overall framing of a project is covered in where to start an industrial lighting renovation.

When partial relamping remains the right choice

Relamping remains entirely relevant in several concrete situations: a room whose layout was calculated recently and is still suitable, a building whose use is due to change in the short term, a secondary area with no task requirement, or cash flow that requires spreading the expenditure over several financial years.

In the latter case, the right approach is to fully renovate the areas with high requirements and long operating hours, then handle the rest by relamping, with LED lamps and tubes for the luminaires kept and linear battens for the areas reworked. The phasing is decided on the plan, with the operating hours of each zone alongside.

To decide zone by zone on your site, book a meeting: we will scope your project and send you a quote.

Further reading: Lighting audit: what we measure during a site visit and Lighting budget: costing your renovation for the next financial year. Reference: EN 12464-1 standard (AFNOR).

On the equipment side, at Rexylum: REXTUB GLASS T8 160LM/W and GKS35-10.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between relamping and a complete lighting renovation?
Relamping means replacing the sources in the existing luminaires, keeping the housings, optics, supports and often the power supply. A complete renovation removes everything and installs new luminaires, with a redefined layout and, where appropriate, a rework of the controls. Intermediate situations exist between the two, and the choice is made zone by zone.
When is simple relamping not enough?
Three signals call for a complete rework: a grid inherited from a layout that no longer exists, uniformity that was already insufficient before the works, and an unsuitable mounting height or optic. In these cases the new source improves consumption without correcting the geometry, and the room remains uncomfortable. A fleet in poor condition, with yellowed diffusers or hardened seals, also argues against relamping.
Does LED relamping void the luminaire warranty?
Yes, the warranty of the original luminaire lapses as soon as its internal wiring is modified. Whoever modifies the luminaire also takes on responsibility for the product thus transformed, with the marking and documentation obligations that go with it. These points are settled before the order, with the contractor who will carry out the works.

Related articles

More articles, those in the same category first.

View all articles
  • Industrial hall with a conveyor, lit by LED luminairesAudit, renovation and profitability

    Lighting budget: costing your renovation for the next financial year

    Lighting renovation cost explained: removal, access equipment, circuit rework and coordination, the items to budget so your LED project holds to the end.

    Luminance ConsultingProfessional lighting design office

    5 min read

  • Workshop workstations lit by LED luminairesAudit, renovation and profitability

    Measuring illuminance with a lux meter: method and pitfalls

    How a lux meter works, where to place the sensor, when to measure and how many points to take: the method for an illuminance reading that stands up.

    Luminance ConsultingProfessional lighting design office

    5 min read

  • Manufacturing hall lit by suspended LED high-bay luminairesAudit, renovation and profitability

    Lighting audit: what we measure during a site visit

    Lux meter readings, inventory of the installed base, compliance gaps: what a lighting audit really contains on an industrial or commercial site.

    Luminance ConsultingProfessional lighting design office

    5 min read